Defending the sanctitiy of the Honey Bee Inn

Final Fantasy VII fans will always find something to be upset about, and today it’s the fact that Square Enix wants to take social changes into account when recreating certain scenes in the Final Fantasy VII Remake.

Specifically, optional scenes set at the Honey Bee Inn, a kind of high-class brothel in Midgar. People think that the issue is an infamous scene where Cloud has to share a bathtub with a bunch of gay bodybuilders. Though, surely the entire Honey Bee Inn has to be handled carefully in order for the end result to be tasteful (and funny)?

The comments over at Siliconera are full of upset gamers whining about “censorship” and “political correctness”. They are asking why people today ar so thin-skinned that they are “triggered” by every little thing? (I am glad that there are also some commenters pointing out that the only people currently flipping out over small details … are the anti-PC brigade.

Now, here’s the thing. A lot of FF7 fans have been deluding themselves into thinking that a remake is a simple and quick affair where you just switch out the old graphics for new graphics and that’s it, the game will naturally retain its original atmosphere and identity.

But no. Having more realistic graphics means that Square Enix must replace the relatively broad, exaggerated animations of the original sprites with more nuanced body language – and with facial expressions. A remake of this caliber will always also be a reinterpretation of the story and characters, because the creators must decide in every cut scene whether a character is going to look worried, amused, afraid, bored, and how they will show this.

So it’s not as if Square Enix would be choosing to question the message and implications of the Honey Bee Inn scene. They have to. Not because evil SJWs are going to boycott them if they don’t, but because that’s what remaking the game actually means. Because they are retelling the story with new words and images and need to decide how exactly to do that in order to get the original, intended meaning across.

But yeah, the content at the Honey Bee Inn deals with sex work, homosexuality and kinky things. It is tricky stuff and should be done thoughtfully, because there is a real danger that these scenes, reinterpreted in a realistic and detailed style, would be offensive today – or that the humour would simply be lost.

Those anti-SJ martyrs should wait with their outrage until we actually see how Square Enix will have chosen to reinterprete these scenes. Maybe it will suck! Maybe it will be hilarious! Who knows? Yes, the average FF7 fan thrives on pessimism and negativity, but it feels like such a waste of energy to be preemptively upset over possible changes to an easter egg in a videogame remake.

Advertisements

2 thoughts on “Defending the sanctitiy of the Honey Bee Inn

  1. Personally, I think this remake is a bad idea. It will never be to everyone what the original game was because what the original game was to everyone is a personal thing between that person and the game.

    Where does Square draw the line? I loved FFX and XII. Can I get remakes of those, preferably on Xbox 360? I liked VIII and IX as well, though if they remake IX, can they please make Zidane capable of actually stealing something?

    This is silly, and all the hype building up to the release of the remake episodes is only going to magnify the (likely irrelevant) problems the whiners and nitpickers are going to find.

    The bit at the Honeybee Inn and Wall Market in the original game was a slump in the game play and story, one of several annoying mini games that players had to suffer through to get to a point where the world finally opens up. (While they’re all slagging off XIII for it’s tight control over location, how can they feel nostalgic about Midgar?).

    Eh, sorry to vent on your post; for what it’s worth, I agree 100% on how remakes are supposed to work. I think the team working on this version would do well with tightening up a lot of the problems with pacing and story that existed with this game.

    • Thank you for your comment! Don’t worry about venting, it’s appreciated. ;) I am a bit torn, to be honest. On the one hand, it’ll be interesting to see a new take on a classic story. Like a new adaptation that makes some different creative choices. On the other hand, you’re right that FF7 fans will probably end up disappointed one way or another! There’s a huge difference between “how FF7 fans remember the game” and “what FF7 was actually like”.

      At least Square Enix is not JUST catering to them, but is also making new games! I’m way more interested in Ikenie To Yuki no Setsuna than in an FF7 remake. I’m hopeful for the future.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s